Academic Rigor
Perceptions of the extent to which students engage in challenging, grade-level learning that requires deep thinking, problem-solving, and application of knowledge across subjects.
Recommendations
Based on our extensive experience, TNTP recommends the following as evidence-based practices for this domain:
- Ensure learning experiences and assignments consistently challenge students to think deeply, solve problems, and apply grade-level knowledge and skills.
- Regularly review instruction, assignments, and student work to ensure expectations remain aligned to rigorous academic standards.
- Share clear examples of grade-level expectations and student work so families and caregivers understand what rigorous learning looks like.
- Provide resources, communication, and opportunities that help families support challenging academic learning beyond the classroom.
- Use coaching, feedback, and collaborative learning opportunities to strengthen rigorous instructional practices across classrooms.
- Celebrate and share examples of high-quality student work and academic growth across the school community.
Resources
Browse Resources by Audience
Teachers
Resources for Teachers
The Opportunity Myth: A report on TNTP’s national research showing that most students lack the opportunity to regularly tackle grade-appropriate assignments
Resources for Selecting Instructional Materials: Resources for reviewing and evaluating instructional materials to ensure rigorous grade-level content
Assignment Review Protocols: Protocols for assessing the quality of assignments students are asked to complete in ELA, math, science, and social studies
Universal Design of Learning Guidelines: A resource on the importance of learner agency
Student Work Library: Examples of assignments that are strongly, partially, and weakly aligned with college and career-ready standards
Good to Great Reflection Guide: A reflection protocol to keep notes on what your students achieve when they’re given the chance to try grade-appropriate assignments
Teachers’ Expectations Survey: A survey to gather information about teachers’ expectations for students
Student Engagement Survey: A survey to understand how engaging and worthwhile students perceived the day’s lesson to be
Adopting Strong Instructional Materials: A case study on supporting the adoption of comprehensive, standards-aligned instructional materials
School Leadership
Resources for School Leadership
Resources for Selecting Instructional Materials: Resources for reviewing and evaluating instructional materials to ensure rigorous grade-level content
Assignment Review Protocols: Protocols for assessing the quality of assignments students are asked to complete in ELA, math, science, and social studies
Adopting Strong Instructional Materials: A case study on supporting the adoption of comprehensive, standards-aligned instructional materials
Central Teams
Resources for Central Teams
Resources for Selecting Instructional Materials: Resources for reviewing and evaluating instructional materials to ensure rigorous grade-level content
Adopting Strong Instructional Materials: A case study on supporting the adoption of comprehensive, standards-aligned instructional materials
Students
Resources for Students
The Opportunity Myth: A report on TNTP’s national research showing that most students lack the opportunity to regularly tackle grade-appropriate assignments
Resources for Selecting Instructional Materials: Resources for reviewing and evaluating instructional materials to ensure rigorous grade-level content
Universal Design of Learning Guidelines: A resource on the importance of learner agency
Student Work Library: Examples of assignments that are strongly, partially, and weakly aligned with college and career-ready standards
Student Engagement Survey: A survey to understand how engaging and worthwhile students perceived the day’s lesson to be